Move 44: offensive Cheese-Scallywag attack vs. defensive face-pulling move

x_p5_248 conflict

In b10, Move 44 is described as an offensive attack move used exclusively by Cheese-Scallywags involving an overpowering smell; in b14, Move 44 (called 'Defence Move 44 / Face Pulling Protective Shield of Hideousness') is described as a defensive face-pulling move used by Dash, Rob and Greta requiring at least 3 combatants -- these are two incompatible descriptions of the same numbered move.

books Book 10 Book 14

subjects Move #44 (The Camembert Vortex)

Evidence

b10 describes Move 44 as an offensive Cheese-Scallywag attack move based on smell	Used by Cheese-scallywags only. This is an extremely powerful move, and when deployed correctly, if the victim is within 20 feet, he or she will faint within seconds because the smell is so bad. Registered 17.9 out of 22 on the (ISS) International Smelliness Scale.	b10:c99:p311
b14 describes Move 44 as a defensive face-pulling move used by Dash, Rob and Greta	we formed Defence Move 44 (Face Pulling Protective Shield of Hideousness) around her.	b14:c10:p234
b14 almanac elaborates Move 44 as needing at least 3 combatants, with face-pulling as its core component	Highly effective defence move. Needs at least 3 combatants to be effective. Dash, Rob and Greta are accomplished deployers of this move.	b14:c99:p324

citations b10:c10:p253 b10:c99:p311 b14:c10:p234 b14:c99:p324

extraction note b10 names the move 'The Camembert Vortex' and attributes it to Cheese-Scallywags as an olfactory attack; b14 names it 'Face Pulling Protective Shield of Hideousness' and attributes it to the heroes as a defensive manoeuvre. Both are labelled Move 44 / Move #44. These descriptions cannot simultaneously hold for the same move number.